What is there to say, but "Read this book and resist bigotry and hatred"? This is one of my favorite Discworlds - I mean, yes, there are so many that I like but this one makes you want to stand up and cheer. And also beg the universe to manifest the upright, plain-dealing Vimes in this reality to please get our world back on track.
Thud, like many a Discworld book, has a lot of threads and themes. Part of what makes it so good is that all those themes hang together really well. (Compare Reaper Man, which I also love, but whose themes are a little more, shall we say, random.) We've got the Where's-My-Cow theme, the identity theme, and the darkness/guarding theme.
Where's My Cow: Vimes reads this book to his son, every night at 6 o'clock. No matter what. In a certain vernacular, we'd say "come hell or high water." We would pointedly not say "God willing and the creek don't rise," because no god or natural disaster is going to stop Vimes from reading to his son.
"Would a minute have mattered? No, probably not, although his young son appeared to have a very accurate internal clock. Possibly even two minutes would be okay. Three minutes, even. You could go to five minutes, perhaps. But that was just it. If you could go for five minutes, then you'd go to ten, then half an hour, a couple of hours...and not see your son all evening. So that was that. Six o'clock, prompt. Every day. Read to young Sam. No excuses. He'd promised himself that. No excuses. No excuses at all. Once you had a good excuse, you opened the door to bad excuses."
Some things matter. And doing the things that matter make us who we are. Drawing a line in the sand, saying this far but no further. "You can't say 'We're the good guys," and do bad-guy things." That's part of what makes Vimes powerful, he recognizes the importance of not just saying, but doing.
I also love this theme for the glimpses of domestic tranquility it provides us. Many stories are about the action, the passion, the heartbreak, the grief. And Discworld has plenty of that - Vimes has plenty of that. But I love seeing Vimes as a father, cuddling and reading to his son, sitting with his wife at home while she darns socks and he reads the paper. These things matter, they are important and valuable.
It is central to Vimes' identity that he read to his son. It means he is a man who loves his family and keeps his promises. It means he has integrity. We also learn what it means to be a dwarf in Thud!, or rather, what being a dwarf isn't. Dwarfishness is not:
1. Being short--Carrot is a very tall dwarf
2. Carrying an axe--Bashfullson says the axe is more in your head
3. Hating trolls--Bashfullson again, saying, "I need no axe to be a dwarf. Nor do I need to hate trolls. What kind of creature defines itself by hatred?"
4. Living underground--city dwarves live quite happily in Ankh-Morpork
5. Being male--Cheery is an out lady dwarf
So what is it, then? What makes a dwarf a dwarf? (What makes a troll a troll, or a human a human?) Well, for dwarves it is knowing and respecting the words, (probably) speaking some dwarvish, and keeping the true traditions. Much like real life, really. How do you become part of a group? Speak their language, do what they do, value what they value.
And when the truth is obscured, they have a way of dealing with it: Mine signs. The most important one in Thud! is the Summoning Dark, a sigil with a vengeance. Scrawled on the walls of mines where things have gone bad, it brings the anger of the beserker: He has wronged me and I will kill him. No need for trial or justice or jury of your peers, only death to the unworthy. The Summoning Dark comes from a place of madness, when things are so bad - truth so obscured - that only death and mayhem can possibly shake things up enough to let the truth out.
And the Summoning Dark tries to get Vimes. Tries to make him its tool. But Vimes is not a tool, Vimes is a man of integrity who reads to his son at 6 o'clock, no excuses. The Summoning Dark fails, brought to heel by Vimes' inner "Guarding Dark," the dark that keeps the others under control. Justice wins the day, Vimes doesn't wholesale slaughter a bunch of dwarven priests, and the truth still comes to light.
Other quotes that are great but I don't know how to fit them into my review:
- Regarding the truth-quelling, Summoning-Dark-bringing, bigoted dwarves and the people who didn't stand up to them: "Or did you say, 'Well, I don't agree with him of course, but he's got a point'? Did you say, 'Oh he goes too far, but it's about time somebody said it'?"
- Regarding accents: "You could barely understand the man, he was that posh. It was not so much speech as modulated yawning."
- Vetinari and Vimes' relationship summed up: What would you do if I asked you an outright questions, Vimes? I would downright lie, sir.
- Regarding the truth: And supposing what it has to say is dreadful? Then we listen!
xo,
Devo
Showing posts with label Terry Pratchett. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Terry Pratchett. Show all posts
Wednesday, April 19, 2017
Saturday, April 8, 2017
Book Review: Reaper Man
Death is a farmer. Snow globes
are cities. Wizards are zombies. This is a whole lotta book.
And I love it. Well, half of it. The b-plot, about
the snow globes and shopping carts and zombie wizard, I’m kind of eh about.
Maybe there’s some big metaphor* about consumer culture and whatnot, but I just…don’t
get it. Please enlighten me in comments if you do.
Anyway. We’re just going to
leave the b-plot aside in favor of the a-plot which is…to die for.
Death, due to cosmic reasons of overly-enthusiastic Auditors
(or Revenoors) thinking he’s gotten too attached to people – too people-like,
if you will – is kicked out of his job and becomes a farm hand. A different
kind of reaper. This is a very blunt** metaphor, but very reasonable. Death, after all, doesn't have a sense of humor. He is hardworking and tireless, so where better to be than a farm? How better to serve than as a reaper?
Though he doesn't really understand us until his time as the reaper Bill Door, Death doesn’t hate humanity. Rather, he loves us. He cares for us. Comes for us in our time but doesn’t see us as a game. We are his duty and his responsibility. We are to be loved
and treated well.
Lord,
what can the harvest hope for if not for the care of the Reaper Man?
Death delivers this line as part
of a beautiful soliloquy/defense of humans to Azrael, the Death of Universes. Discworld
Death is only a minor death, it turns out. Which I kind of love. Throughout the
series of books, Death is a major player – he appears in nearly every novel, and
has a whole subseries to himself. Death comes to everybody on the Disc, great
and small, important to the plot or not. But even this giant skeleton who holds
the timers of all life in the world, even he is dwarfed. There is something
bigger, something more mysterious, something more final and more old, and that is the great Azrael.
Little girls rescued from fires,
old women living in sadness, farmers worried about rain and food, old
men drinking in a pub, shopkeepers looking to make a buck – these are the
people Death encounters. These ordinary people are who inspire Death to
challenge the Auditors, stand up before Azrael and say, Listen. See what I have
seen. Feel what I have felt, as much as I could with my skeleton heart.
Understand that these people matter, though their lives are so much nothing in
the eons of eternity. Understand that Miss Flitworth, whose story of love cut
short too soon, though only one of many, one of thousands or tens of thousands –
it matters to her. And she matters to me.
Lord,
we know that there is no good order except that which we create…there is no
hope but us. There is no mercy but us. There is no justice. There is just us.
All
things that are, are ours. But we must care. For if we do not care, we do not
exist. If we do not exist, then there is nothing but blind oblivion.
And
even oblivion must end some day. Lord, will you grant me just a little time?
For the proper balance of things. To return what was given. For the sake of
prisoners and the flight of birds.
Miss Flitworth gave Death some
of her life-time, to battle the incumbent Death placed by the Auditors.
Even life-time to grab a scythe with corporeal fingers and throw a monkey
wrench (or rather, a three-eighths gripley) into the unfeeling machine of the Auditors’
puppet.
In return, Death goes to the end
of Time to ask for her life back. To ask that she be given a gift in return for
her sacrifice. Death teaches us to look out for our friends, with whatever
means we have. And while no, it may not be entirely fair or orderly that Miss
Flitworth gets her time as a young girl with her love back, since she had the
one thing on her side that could approach Azrael and ask for it, it was kind. And that is what's important.
Lord,
what can the harvest hope for if not for the care of the Reaper Man?
xo,
Devo
*which is like lying, only more
decorative
** or rather, sharp
Friday, June 17, 2016
Book review: Pratchett Quadruple Feature
When I started this post, I thought it was just going to be a double feature: Feet of Clay and Unseen Academicals. Then I realized I hadn't yet talked about Amazing Maurice and His Educated Rodents or Carpe Jugulum. So strap yourselves in and let's go for a four-book ride on the back of the world turtle.
We begin with the one-off; that is, the one I can't tie readily to the other three. Amazing Maurice!
Brief synopsis: Maurice is a talking cat and a con-artist, who works with a bunch of talking rats who are in search of rat paradise. Or rat utopia. Or something.
Briefer synopsis: Pratchett takes on the myth of the pied piper.
Briefest synopsis: Cats and rats and death.
Sir Terry gives some advice: "A good plan isn’t one where someone wins, it’s where nobody thinks they’ve lost." He makes some snarky observations about cats: "I’M SURPRISED AT YOU, MAURICE. OF COURSE THERE ARE NO CAT GODS. THAT WOULD BE TOO MUCH LIKE WORK." He defies germ theory: "Life’s bad enough as it is without having to worry about invisible things you can’t see!"
Battles are fought and lives are lost and people are freed, from their literal and metaphorical shackles. It's the whole Pratchett package.
Next, let's visit the witches, the watch, and the wizards. Of the three, the witches are my favorite, the watch next, and the wizards? Eh, they're alright.
CJ has the redoubtable trio of Ogg, Weatherwax, and Nitt dealing with mind-altering vampires.
I just love their characterization and depth. Nanny is always ready with a smile and pick-me-up: "Oh, we’re always alright. You remember that. We happen to other people." Granny is always ready with a frown and some (not always nice) truth: "Don’t trust the cannibal just ‘cos he’s usin’ a knife and fork!" And Agnes is always plowing through some self-doubt and reminding us that we may not be born witches, but can become so. That even the most mousey can have some vim: "It was the sort of grin that Agnes supposed was called infectious but, then, so was measles."
Agnes ain't having with no jumped-up, mind-bending vampire. No matter how pretty he is.
CJ is where Ankh-Morpork's strategy breaks down - letting the siege-rs in doesn't work this time. It usually does. We see it play out countless times on the Disc. But that's why you need Granny, and Nanny and the whole witch crew. To stand at the boundaries between light and dark. To make hard decisions. To say, "No. We will not be bamboozled by your glamor. We will not hand ourselves over to you."
***
UA and FC both deal with creatures getting their "humanity" - because in the end, Terry believes in humanity. He believes that it's worth it. That humanity is something to strive for. This also crops up in The Next Generation, and exploring what it means to be human is one of my favorite things that sci-fi does. "The Measure of a Man," regarding Data's humanity, is quite possibly the best Trek episode; go forth to Netflix and behold your humanity!
Anyway.
FC deals with slavery and self-determination and responsibility and government. It is, admittedly, a bit heavy. But this line? This I wanted to shout from the rooftops, wonky capitalization and all: "In the Fyres of Struggle let us bake New Men, who Will Notte heed the Old Lies." Let us make new mistakes, not old ones. Let us learn.
UA is lighter, about football (soccer), Romeo and Juliet, and cooking. So much cooking. Cooking as therapy ("Nothing cleans stubborn stains like suppressed anger."), cooking as metaphor, cooking as safety. Food unlocks doors. Food unites. Food is life.
***
We begin with the one-off; that is, the one I can't tie readily to the other three. Amazing Maurice!
Brief synopsis: Maurice is a talking cat and a con-artist, who works with a bunch of talking rats who are in search of rat paradise. Or rat utopia. Or something.
Briefer synopsis: Pratchett takes on the myth of the pied piper.
Briefest synopsis: Cats and rats and death.
Sir Terry gives some advice: "A good plan isn’t one where someone wins, it’s where nobody thinks they’ve lost." He makes some snarky observations about cats: "I’M SURPRISED AT YOU, MAURICE. OF COURSE THERE ARE NO CAT GODS. THAT WOULD BE TOO MUCH LIKE WORK." He defies germ theory: "Life’s bad enough as it is without having to worry about invisible things you can’t see!"
Battles are fought and lives are lost and people are freed, from their literal and metaphorical shackles. It's the whole Pratchett package.
***
CJ has the redoubtable trio of Ogg, Weatherwax, and Nitt dealing with mind-altering vampires.
I just love their characterization and depth. Nanny is always ready with a smile and pick-me-up: "Oh, we’re always alright. You remember that. We happen to other people." Granny is always ready with a frown and some (not always nice) truth: "Don’t trust the cannibal just ‘cos he’s usin’ a knife and fork!" And Agnes is always plowing through some self-doubt and reminding us that we may not be born witches, but can become so. That even the most mousey can have some vim: "It was the sort of grin that Agnes supposed was called infectious but, then, so was measles."
Agnes ain't having with no jumped-up, mind-bending vampire. No matter how pretty he is.
CJ is where Ankh-Morpork's strategy breaks down - letting the siege-rs in doesn't work this time. It usually does. We see it play out countless times on the Disc. But that's why you need Granny, and Nanny and the whole witch crew. To stand at the boundaries between light and dark. To make hard decisions. To say, "No. We will not be bamboozled by your glamor. We will not hand ourselves over to you."
***
UA and FC both deal with creatures getting their "humanity" - because in the end, Terry believes in humanity. He believes that it's worth it. That humanity is something to strive for. This also crops up in The Next Generation, and exploring what it means to be human is one of my favorite things that sci-fi does. "The Measure of a Man," regarding Data's humanity, is quite possibly the best Trek episode; go forth to Netflix and behold your humanity!
Anyway.
FC deals with slavery and self-determination and responsibility and government. It is, admittedly, a bit heavy. But this line? This I wanted to shout from the rooftops, wonky capitalization and all: "In the Fyres of Struggle let us bake New Men, who Will Notte heed the Old Lies." Let us make new mistakes, not old ones. Let us learn.
UA is lighter, about football (soccer), Romeo and Juliet, and cooking. So much cooking. Cooking as therapy ("Nothing cleans stubborn stains like suppressed anger."), cooking as metaphor, cooking as safety. Food unlocks doors. Food unites. Food is life.
***
As I said before, I like the witches better than the wizards. However, both understand and respect the magic system of Discworld: don't use too much or you'll screw things up. I think that's why this series works so well as a fantasy series, or at least why I, a hater of fantasy, like it so much. Pratchett puts constraints on the world that make it NOT magical, or at least not overwhelmingly so. Then, what's left to deal in is the human stuff, the real stuff.
I don't read Discworld because I'm particularly into football, or the postal system, or dwarf battles, or the fashion industry. I read it because it teaches me about being human, about valuing being human. It teaches me to question, to explore, to not accept the surface version of the truth. It teaches me to stand up and shout when necessary, and to retreat when appropriate. It teaches me.
xo,
Devo
Incidentally, if anybody wants to buy me this illustrated copy of Mort, I wouldn't say no.
Friday, February 5, 2016
Book review (sort of): Nanny Ogg's Cookbook
Despite having just read The Big Short (and understood maaaaaybe 30% of it), I just can't gear myself up to write about it. There's a movie out, I hear, so maybe go watch that. Or read this review of the movie and the book, get two-for-one, and call it a day. Anyway, the point is: I might get around to writing about it, I might not.
So even though I was a bona-fide adult and read a difficult book about perhaps the realest real-world issue of the modern age, I'm gonna talk about Nanny Ogg and her cookbook.
I love this daffy book so much. It probably helps that I enjoy reading *actual* cookbooks and etiquette books (Miss Manners and her incomparable sass FTW!). Nanny Ogg is a bit much, it's true, but she's a jolly old lady who loves a pun, an innuendo, a snack, and a smashing of the patriarchy. Which really is a character type I think we need more of in modern entertainment.
The Cookbook has much to recommend it, including the aforementioned puns and lots of great one-liners ("Gumbo is one of those dishes, like stew, where it’s ridiculous to have a recipe. You just make it."). It's also an etiquette guide, with perhaps the pro-i-est of LPTs you'll ever encounter. Because if there's one thing Nanny Ogg's good at, it's livin' it up.
What has been specifically on my mind recently though, is her recipe for dried frog pills, which begins, "Carefully take no frogs." This recipe really speaks to me, because I am prone to ignoring large swaths of instructions when cooking. Nanny just takes it a step further and ignores the main ingredient.
So, without further ado, here is an incomplete list of what I read vs. what I do [1]
Whisk ----- use a fork
peel ----- never peel
anything less than 1 tsp ----- guess
sift ----- nobody has time to sift
fresh [herb] ------ used dried, because who has a year-round herb patch?
any measure raisins ----- more raisins
and finally, the frog-inspired one...
saffron ----- do not use saffron
xo,
Devo
So even though I was a bona-fide adult and read a difficult book about perhaps the realest real-world issue of the modern age, I'm gonna talk about Nanny Ogg and her cookbook.
I love this daffy book so much. It probably helps that I enjoy reading *actual* cookbooks and etiquette books (Miss Manners and her incomparable sass FTW!). Nanny Ogg is a bit much, it's true, but she's a jolly old lady who loves a pun, an innuendo, a snack, and a smashing of the patriarchy. Which really is a character type I think we need more of in modern entertainment.
The Cookbook has much to recommend it, including the aforementioned puns and lots of great one-liners ("Gumbo is one of those dishes, like stew, where it’s ridiculous to have a recipe. You just make it."). It's also an etiquette guide, with perhaps the pro-i-est of LPTs you'll ever encounter. Because if there's one thing Nanny Ogg's good at, it's livin' it up.
What has been specifically on my mind recently though, is her recipe for dried frog pills, which begins, "Carefully take no frogs." This recipe really speaks to me, because I am prone to ignoring large swaths of instructions when cooking. Nanny just takes it a step further and ignores the main ingredient.
So, without further ado, here is an incomplete list of what I read vs. what I do [1]
This is also know as the Hannah Hart Cooking Method, which is amply demonstrated on her show, My Drunk Kitchen.
Whisk ----- use a fork
peel ----- never peel
anything less than 1 tsp ----- guess
sift ----- nobody has time to sift
fresh [herb] ------ used dried, because who has a year-round herb patch?
any measure raisins ----- more raisins
and finally, the frog-inspired one...
saffron ----- do not use saffron
xo,
Devo
Tuesday, January 5, 2016
Book reviews, shortform
Here's what I've read since last I checked in - didn't take good notes on any of them. Tried to write some longform reviews, but they're just not happening . So you get brevity instead - which is the soul of wit, n'est-ce pas? [1]
Strong Poison and Gaudy Night by Dorothy L. Sayers. While I think there are some intervening novels, I read these back-to-back, cutting out the usually-dragging middle. Peter Wimsey is the detective of this whole mystery series, though these two form a little story-within-a-story. And hilariously, although the cover of GN touts Wimsey as being "at his deductive best!", he doesn't show up until about three-quarters of the way though the book. I'm not terribly into mystery novels (though I do love a good mystery on Netflix for crocheting to), but these were funny and linguistically interesting. I don't find the plots of mysteries terribly engaging: somebody dunnit and we're going to find out who. That's all that happens, more or less. But if it's an amusing ride to get there, then I'm all for it. GN drags some at the beginning, but is overall enjoyable.
Witches Abroad by Terry Pratchett. Nanny and Granny take on Cinderella. I ended up watching Branagh's Cinderella in the midst of reading, and it was interesting to have a very straight version (movie) against a very deconstructed version (Pratchett. Always Pratchett.) As a sidenote, I had to convince someone that they had indeed heard of the Great A'Tuin, despite them only having read Guards! Guards!, because it shows up in nearly every book. It wasn't at the beginning, alas, but flip to the end, and lo and behold, there the Great A'Tuin was, serenely gliding through space with its accompanying elephants.
The Autistic Brain by Temple Grandin. Mostly interesting (despite her enthusiasm for brain scans, I wasn't super into that part). Brings up good points about focusing on skills rather than deficits, pairing one person's strengths with another's weaknesses, the large role played by sensory overstimulation in autism, and a proposal (with evidence) to think about 3 kinds of autistic/neurotypical brains: picture, word, and pattern.
***
Genres
1 non-fiction, 3 fiction, 1 pratchett.
Here's what I'm about to read: Emergence: Labeled Autistic by Temple Grandin
xo,
Devo
[1] Pretencious French alert
Friday, November 6, 2015
I am overwhelmed by the sheer number of reviews I could theoretically write
Here's what I've read (semi-recently) and not blogged about:
1. A Slip of the Keyboard by Terry Pratchett
1. A Slip of the Keyboard by Terry Pratchett
Collection of Pratchett's non-fiction. Quite enjoyable, though got a bit repetitive at the end, which was many essays advocating for the right to assisted suicide/death with dignity [1]. Good quote (besides the entire thing): "[A]t its best science fiction is about us and our Faustian bargain with our big brains, which dragged us out of the trees but may yet drag us into the volcano." He talks about many things in this collection, including the power/aggravation of his Author Hat, the importance of writing and reading fantasy, and working at a nuclear power plant and the myths that spring up there. If you're a fan, read it.
2. Nation by Terry Pratchett
2. Nation by Terry Pratchett
Prompted by his mentioning in the above that he considers this his best work. Good and compelling and quotable, as all of Sir Terry is. The fantasy is minimal, more of historical-legend type than the wizard/dwarf/vampire mix of the Discworld. So if you want to try Pratchett but HATE fantasy, try this one. (Though I hate -high- fantasy, and LOVE Discworld.) Good quote: "If a lie will make us strong, a lie will be my weapon."
3. Two Old Women by Velma Wallis
3. Two Old Women by Velma Wallis
Alaskan legend, about, you guessed it, two old women, and their successful fight to survive the winter when abandoned by their tribe. If you liked My Side of the Mountain as a kid, try this one. Much shorter (more novella than novel), but hey, I learned things about trapping rabbits and hunting moose that I never knew before.
4. The Women of Brewster Place by Gloria Naylor
4. The Women of Brewster Place by Gloria Naylor
Such a good book, but so depressing in many places. There are 5? 7? 9? (it's been a while) stories, each relating to but not dependent on the others. Usually such a device aggravates me, but these are distinct, and they don't switch back to previous POVs. [2]
5. Maskerade by Terry Pratchett
5. Maskerade by Terry Pratchett
Terry's take on Phantom of the Opera, complete with old, sassy witches. Nanny and Granny are such delightful characters, and great foils to one another. I love it that people are not reduced to one category or label in the Discworld. There are many good ways to be a witch, and all are equally valid and helpful. You can be young and fierce (Tiffany), young and timid (Perdita nee Agnes Nitt), old and raunchy (Nanny), or old and tight-laced (Granny). Witching requires being able to see things for what they are, analyze them, and then do what needs doing to heal/help/prod/change/fix. K. doesn't like the witches so much, but I sure do. Good quote: "Nanny Ogg usually went to bed early. After all, she was an old lady. Sometimes she went to bed as early as six A.M."
6. The Shepherd’s Crown by Terry Pratchett
6. The Shepherd’s Crown by Terry Pratchett
The last of the Discworld. Short and less polished, due to his dying before completely finishing the text, but very moving. A good ending, though sad.
7. Being Mortal by Atul Gawande
7. Being Mortal by Atul Gawande
And more about death, this time from a surgeon. Related to but not entirely like How We Die. Where the latter deals with the literal mechanisms of death, this deals with the moments before death, how physicians and families of the elderly or the terminally ill can better prepare for the end, the benefits of hospice, etc. I found the most thought-provoking part to be making sure to converse loved about what "life" means to a given individual, and that doctors should give recomendations for treatment based on those discussions. That is, it does no good to prolong a person's biochemical life if they have nothing worth living for. So, for one of his patients, it would remain worth it to stay alive (undergo surgery, chemo, etc) for being able to watch football and eat chocolate ice cream. On the other hand, for his father, life was meaningless if he could no longer interact with people and maintain a certain level of autonomy. So in both cases, when surgeries and treatments could no longer preserve those things, the medicine turned to palliative care, rather than aggressive procedures.
8. The Ghost in My Brain by Clark Elliott
8. The Ghost in My Brain by Clark Elliott
Meh. Generally too wordy and repetitive, though it is incredible that the author a) managed to keep teaching and taking care of his children despite not being able to think [give focused attention to anything] more than a few minutes at a time and b) recover an incredible amount of brain function eight years after his concussion. Read The Brain That Changes Itself instead, or at least first.
9. 400 Things Cops Know by Adam Plantinga
9. 400 Things Cops Know by Adam Plantinga
This is frequently hilarious (though sometimes you feel bad laughing, you just can't help yourself) and always informative. He writes with alacrity and realness. And if you like Pratchett's Watch series, you'll see Vimes all over this book. Good quote: "Keep in mind the old law enforcement adage that sounds like a country song: The Only Person I Trust Is My Mother And I Ain't Even Too Sure About Her."
10. Jingo by Terry Pratchett
Sir Terry takes on war. I like this one better than his other take on war (Men at Arms). It's got more Vimes, for one thing, which is always a plus. Who else could decide that the proper response to imminent, race-hatred-fueled warfare is to arrest entire countries? Good quote: "Theft was the only crime, whether the loot was gold, innocence, land or life."
11. Fast Breaks by Phony McFakename
Proofread for a friend. Bizzaro fiction, and also some zombie short stories. The bizarro stuff's not my jam, but "The Most Amazing Story Ever" and "Dawn of the Wed" are enjoyable.
Genres
Fiction: 3, 4, 11
Non-fiction: 1, 7, 8, 9
Pratchett: 1, 2, 5, 6, 10
***
Here's what I'm in the process of reading: Strong Poison by Dorothy L. Sayers
Here's what I'm about to read: Sorcery and Pyramids by Terry Pratchett, The Life Changing Magic of Tidying Up by Marie Kondo
Here's what I want to re-read, having now finally watched the movie: Howl's Moving Castle by Diana Wynn Jones
...and there you have it. The book update. Bam.
xo,
Devo
[1] Choose your term, depending on which side of the debate you fall.
[2] Maybe I'm just a lazy reader slash don't like cliff hangers, but I just loathe having to keep up with a POV switching book. I have to remember whose voice I'm reading, what they know and don't know compared to the other POV character, who's where and just nonsense.
Thursday, March 12, 2015
Here's to you, Sir Terry
I love Pratchett's writing, no secret there. He died today. Here are some of his words.
On priorities:
“Hat
= wizard. Wizard = hat. Everything else is frippery.” – Ridcully
On hope:
What
good’s a god who gives you everything you want? … It’s the hope that’s important. Big part of belief, hope.
On fear:
In
order to fear, you had to be a me.
Don’t let anything happen to me. That
was the song of fear.
On literary devices:
Going Up in the World is a metaphor, which…is
like Lying but more decorative.
On cooking:
Gumbo
is one of those dishes, like stew, where it’s ridiculous to have a recipe. You
just make it.
On death.
WHERE THE FIRST PRIMAL CELL WAS, THERE WAS I ALSO. WHERE MAN IS, THERE AM I. WHEN THE LAST LIFE CRAWLS UNDER FREEZING STARS, THERE WILL I BE.
xo,
Devo
Quotes from Guards! Guards!, Mort, Night Watch, Nanny Ogg's Cookbook, Hogfather, and Thief of Time
Monday, February 23, 2015
Book review: The Folklore of Discworld
Okay, so I'm a little slow on this one, and started reading another book [1] before writing this review. But I was trying to take the advice of End of Absence and go off the grid for a little, tiny bit.
Anyway. Folklore.
This was a fun look at the myffic [2] and narrative parallels between Discworld and earth. I have to admit that I skipped most of the earth-centric bits, in favor of learning about the Discworld creatures and legends, but had I been more dedicated/historically minded, I'm sure those parts would have been nice, too. As it was, I chuckled at the description of the Nac Mac Feegle and got a few ideas for which Discworld books to read next.
It was, at times, a bit dry, since it's more of a reference book than a story. But it would be an excellent companion book if you are, say, like my friend K., reading the series in chronological-written order from start to finish. Then it would be handy to learn about the dwarves of the Disc as you read their books, or the Temperance League of vampires.
While Folklore ties together many interesting bits of story and hearsay, in the end, it's not really clear why people have these stories. And that's alright. After all, "Legends don't have to make sense. They just have to be beautiful. Or at least interesting."
xo,
Devo
[1] We'll see how it goes, since it's fiction but not Discworld.
[2] Quoth the Raven
Anyway. Folklore.
This was a fun look at the myffic [2] and narrative parallels between Discworld and earth. I have to admit that I skipped most of the earth-centric bits, in favor of learning about the Discworld creatures and legends, but had I been more dedicated/historically minded, I'm sure those parts would have been nice, too. As it was, I chuckled at the description of the Nac Mac Feegle and got a few ideas for which Discworld books to read next.
It was, at times, a bit dry, since it's more of a reference book than a story. But it would be an excellent companion book if you are, say, like my friend K., reading the series in chronological-written order from start to finish. Then it would be handy to learn about the dwarves of the Disc as you read their books, or the Temperance League of vampires.
While Folklore ties together many interesting bits of story and hearsay, in the end, it's not really clear why people have these stories. And that's alright. After all, "Legends don't have to make sense. They just have to be beautiful. Or at least interesting."
xo,
Devo
[1] We'll see how it goes, since it's fiction but not Discworld.
[2] Quoth the Raven
Friday, January 30, 2015
Book Review: Night Watch
My life recently has been one big Terry Pratchett fest: read Hogfather, watched Hogfather [1], and finished Night Watch. [2]
Night Watch is about time travel (shout out to quantums!), semi- to entirely-corrupt government officials, and Les Mis. The last one maybe not on purpose (but then again, since it's Pratchett, maybe very much on purpose; the man never met an allusion or a pun he wouldn't include), but when you write about police and revolutions and barricades, there's bound to be Les Mis overtones. And overtures. And solos. Honestly, in the latter part of Night Watch, I was just warbling, "Do You Hear the People Sing?" while reading about the Peoples' Republic of Treacle Mine Road. The French Revolution may have given us Liberté, Égalité, Fraternité, but Treacle Mine Road is all for Truth, Justice, Freedom, Reasonably-Priced Love, and a Hard-Boiled Egg.
This slogan encapsulates the spirit of Night Watch, and maybe the entire ethos of Discworld. Things are hard and dire, belief must be saved, justice and honor must struggle to prevail - but the world is also sometimes just daffy. Sir Terry gets into a lot of heavy stuff in this series: mortality, religion, belief, the afterlife, government brutality, the nature of God(s), and so on, and all are treated with intelligence and nuance. But the Discworld is also - thank goodness - full of humor and slightly snarky send-ups of humanity's foibles, follies, and conceits.
Abrupt transition! Because it's not school and I can change paragraphs with no segues if I want! Here, have a random picture of a flower, because I have lots.
I love when Pratchett, or any author, for that matter, makes me think about words - I love a good story, don't get me wrong, but I also love it when a writer loves the words on the page for themselves, uses the medium as part and parcel of the message, not just as a vehicle. I love the many layers of language, and I love it when a new layer [3] is revealed. Think Lyra from The Golden Compass, she being able to operate the eponymous compass because of her understanding of the many permutations and meanings of a symbol. And language is, after all, no more than a set of symbols.
Anyway. I've rambled down a somewhat lengthy digression, but the point is this quote, spoken by Vimes, the time-travelling (it was accidental, due to lighting and magic and quantums) policeman: "Don't put your trust in revolutions. They always come around again. That's why they're called revolutions. People die and nothing changes."
Yeah. Sometimes Discworld novels are depressing.
But not to fret! They're also amusing and wry. [4] Pratchett knows the value of acting - that sometimes pretending is near enough to the real thing to get the job done. That sometimes, we must assume a virtue we have not, must act as though we know what we're doing in order to continue on. When Vimes is thrown into his own past and tasked with teaching his younger self how to be an honorable and effective copper, we (and he) are reminded that "The key to winning, as always, was looking as if you had every right, nay, duty, to be where you were. It helped if you could also suggest in every line of your body that no one else had any rights to be doing anything, anywhere, whatsoever."
As always, give it a read. Night Watch, like all Discworld novels, provides two things the world needs more of: laughter and deep thinks.
**Also, bonus book review of Freakonomics, which I did indeed read but was slightly sick during, so I don't really have much to say . The short of it is: It's good, but I liked Think Like a Freak better. Two gems that I wrote down in my sick stupor: "Information is a beacon, a cudgel, an olive branch, a deterrent, depending on who wields it and how." and "...emotion is the enemy of rational argument." My SO, the psych major, says that emotion is in fact a very important decision-making tool, and had a bit of a harrumph when I read this second quote. And as Forrest Gump would say, that is all I have to say about that.**
xo,
Devo
[1] Starring Michelle Dockery, of Downton Abbey fame. And yes, it was just as weird as you'd expect to see Lady Mary as a governess.
[2] I should figure out how to put a counter on this blog, so I can count up to 1000-book party.
[3] "Cakes! Cakes have layers!" "Ogres. Are not. Like cakes."
[4] This duality being rather like life, really.
Night Watch is about time travel (shout out to quantums!), semi- to entirely-corrupt government officials, and Les Mis. The last one maybe not on purpose (but then again, since it's Pratchett, maybe very much on purpose; the man never met an allusion or a pun he wouldn't include), but when you write about police and revolutions and barricades, there's bound to be Les Mis overtones. And overtures. And solos. Honestly, in the latter part of Night Watch, I was just warbling, "Do You Hear the People Sing?" while reading about the Peoples' Republic of Treacle Mine Road. The French Revolution may have given us Liberté, Égalité, Fraternité, but Treacle Mine Road is all for Truth, Justice, Freedom, Reasonably-Priced Love, and a Hard-Boiled Egg.
This slogan encapsulates the spirit of Night Watch, and maybe the entire ethos of Discworld. Things are hard and dire, belief must be saved, justice and honor must struggle to prevail - but the world is also sometimes just daffy. Sir Terry gets into a lot of heavy stuff in this series: mortality, religion, belief, the afterlife, government brutality, the nature of God(s), and so on, and all are treated with intelligence and nuance. But the Discworld is also - thank goodness - full of humor and slightly snarky send-ups of humanity's foibles, follies, and conceits.
Abrupt transition! Because it's not school and I can change paragraphs with no segues if I want! Here, have a random picture of a flower, because I have lots.
| Wouldn't it be nice if every topic shift in an academic paper was preceded by a flower picture? |
I love when Pratchett, or any author, for that matter, makes me think about words - I love a good story, don't get me wrong, but I also love it when a writer loves the words on the page for themselves, uses the medium as part and parcel of the message, not just as a vehicle. I love the many layers of language, and I love it when a new layer [3] is revealed. Think Lyra from The Golden Compass, she being able to operate the eponymous compass because of her understanding of the many permutations and meanings of a symbol. And language is, after all, no more than a set of symbols.
Anyway. I've rambled down a somewhat lengthy digression, but the point is this quote, spoken by Vimes, the time-travelling (it was accidental, due to lighting and magic and quantums) policeman: "Don't put your trust in revolutions. They always come around again. That's why they're called revolutions. People die and nothing changes."
Yeah. Sometimes Discworld novels are depressing.
But not to fret! They're also amusing and wry. [4] Pratchett knows the value of acting - that sometimes pretending is near enough to the real thing to get the job done. That sometimes, we must assume a virtue we have not, must act as though we know what we're doing in order to continue on. When Vimes is thrown into his own past and tasked with teaching his younger self how to be an honorable and effective copper, we (and he) are reminded that "The key to winning, as always, was looking as if you had every right, nay, duty, to be where you were. It helped if you could also suggest in every line of your body that no one else had any rights to be doing anything, anywhere, whatsoever."
As always, give it a read. Night Watch, like all Discworld novels, provides two things the world needs more of: laughter and deep thinks.
**Also, bonus book review of Freakonomics, which I did indeed read but was slightly sick during, so I don't really have much to say . The short of it is: It's good, but I liked Think Like a Freak better. Two gems that I wrote down in my sick stupor: "Information is a beacon, a cudgel, an olive branch, a deterrent, depending on who wields it and how." and "...emotion is the enemy of rational argument." My SO, the psych major, says that emotion is in fact a very important decision-making tool, and had a bit of a harrumph when I read this second quote. And as Forrest Gump would say, that is all I have to say about that.**
xo,
Devo
[1] Starring Michelle Dockery, of Downton Abbey fame. And yes, it was just as weird as you'd expect to see Lady Mary as a governess.
[2] I should figure out how to put a counter on this blog, so I can count up to 1000-book party.
[3] "Cakes! Cakes have layers!" "Ogres. Are not. Like cakes."
[4] This duality being rather like life, really.
Thursday, January 8, 2015
Book review: Hogfather
Up for three hours in the middle of the night. Typing on somebody else's laptop. Matters not - the new method dictates that I write the blog post directly after finishing the book. So here it goes; please forgive any incoherency.
I do love a Terry Pratchett novel. So much. He takes on any subject with aplomb and many opinions. Hogfather is, perhaps unexpectedly, about Christmas - or "Hogswatchnight," if you will. But of course, since it's Pratchett, it's not really about Christmas. It's about belief and stories and magic and death and computers and AI and being sensible. And somehow, through the magic and wit that is Sir Terry, it all works remarkably well.
Pratchett's novels (at least the one's I've read thus far - there are about a billion and a half, so other themes are bound to show up) often deal with belief: the nature of, how to encourage it, what happens when it ceases. In the Discworld, things exist because people believe in them, those things being gods, Death, the Verruca Gnome, or the Hogfather. His characters wax philosophical, saying, "What good's a god who gives you everything you want? ...It's the hope that's important. Big part of belief, hope." Yes, Discworld novels are full of ridiculous puns, and daffy wizards, and sometimes head-scratching plotting [0] - but then there are jewels like this. Thoughts about the nature of belief that make you (or at least me) go, "Huh. Yeah. I maybe actually really agree with that."
Lest we think that it's all high phrases and deep philosophy, Pratchett also puts us in our place - humans, he often writes, are rather ridiculous and sometimes very stupid. We have our redeeming qualities, sure; the ability to believe, to tell stories, to be kind. But just in case we're getting too big for our britches, Pratchett has the almost-sentient computer Hex state, +++Humans Are Not Always Wrong+++ [0.5]. I have a whole different blogpost to come about double negation/counterfactuals, but suffice it to say that "not-negative" isn't the same as "positive" (Think about "I liked him" vs. "I didn't not like him"). "Humans are not always wrong" is quite different from "Humans are frequently right."
We also get this sassy bit of dialog between two wizards (wizards, of course, being parodies of academics): "He [Hex, the almost-or-rather-very-nearly-certainly sentient computer] just looks like he's thinking, right?" "Er...yes." "But he's not actually thinking?" "Er...no." "So...he just gives the impression of thinking but really it's just a show?" "Er...yes." "Just like everyone else, then, really." Humans are beautiful, Pratchett says - so complex and interesting that Death and War and other anthropomorphic embodiements of ideas are drawn to them and pick up their characteristics; yes, they are beautiful, but they're also lazy, and somewhat silly.
But before I get utterly derailed meditating on human follies and fortunes, back to Hogfather. Ancient magic gets repurposed to new jobs. It's very much a "conservation of matter" law, except in the context of belief and magic. In the case of the Hogfather - he who was once god of Thunder and Sunrises is now the jolly, toy-giving Spirit ofChristmas Hogswatch. [1] Our belief shape us, Pratchett shows us, but also and perhaps more importantly, we shape them. We are the stories we tell ourselves.
And one final quote from Hogfather, because it's just so quotable. One of the wizards wants to interview (at length) somebody's who's been resuscitated: "I really should talk to him, sir. He's had a near-death experience!" To which his superior replies, "We all have. It's called 'living.' "
xo,
Devo
[0] The shopping carts and snow globes ofThief of Time Reaper Man, anyone?
[0.5] Another thing I love about Pratchett's novels is the use of different typography/punctuation conventions to convey non-human speech. The computer gets +++Something Like This+++, Death speaks in small caps (which of course I can't figure out how to do on this machine), and the Auditors get no quotation marks.
[1] Ancient magic makes me think of Card's Enchantment, to which, if I were more awake, I'd draw some more comparisons.
I do love a Terry Pratchett novel. So much. He takes on any subject with aplomb and many opinions. Hogfather is, perhaps unexpectedly, about Christmas - or "Hogswatchnight," if you will. But of course, since it's Pratchett, it's not really about Christmas. It's about belief and stories and magic and death and computers and AI and being sensible. And somehow, through the magic and wit that is Sir Terry, it all works remarkably well.
Pratchett's novels (at least the one's I've read thus far - there are about a billion and a half, so other themes are bound to show up) often deal with belief: the nature of, how to encourage it, what happens when it ceases. In the Discworld, things exist because people believe in them, those things being gods, Death, the Verruca Gnome, or the Hogfather. His characters wax philosophical, saying, "What good's a god who gives you everything you want? ...It's the hope that's important. Big part of belief, hope." Yes, Discworld novels are full of ridiculous puns, and daffy wizards, and sometimes head-scratching plotting [0] - but then there are jewels like this. Thoughts about the nature of belief that make you (or at least me) go, "Huh. Yeah. I maybe actually really agree with that."
Lest we think that it's all high phrases and deep philosophy, Pratchett also puts us in our place - humans, he often writes, are rather ridiculous and sometimes very stupid. We have our redeeming qualities, sure; the ability to believe, to tell stories, to be kind. But just in case we're getting too big for our britches, Pratchett has the almost-sentient computer Hex state, +++Humans Are Not Always Wrong+++ [0.5]. I have a whole different blogpost to come about double negation/counterfactuals, but suffice it to say that "not-negative" isn't the same as "positive" (Think about "I liked him" vs. "I didn't not like him"). "Humans are not always wrong" is quite different from "Humans are frequently right."
We also get this sassy bit of dialog between two wizards (wizards, of course, being parodies of academics): "He [Hex, the almost-or-rather-very-nearly-certainly sentient computer] just looks like he's thinking, right?" "Er...yes." "But he's not actually thinking?" "Er...no." "So...he just gives the impression of thinking but really it's just a show?" "Er...yes." "Just like everyone else, then, really." Humans are beautiful, Pratchett says - so complex and interesting that Death and War and other anthropomorphic embodiements of ideas are drawn to them and pick up their characteristics; yes, they are beautiful, but they're also lazy, and somewhat silly.
But before I get utterly derailed meditating on human follies and fortunes, back to Hogfather. Ancient magic gets repurposed to new jobs. It's very much a "conservation of matter" law, except in the context of belief and magic. In the case of the Hogfather - he who was once god of Thunder and Sunrises is now the jolly, toy-giving Spirit of
And one final quote from Hogfather, because it's just so quotable. One of the wizards wants to interview (at length) somebody's who's been resuscitated: "I really should talk to him, sir. He's had a near-death experience!" To which his superior replies, "We all have. It's called 'living.' "
xo,
Devo
[0] The shopping carts and snow globes of
[0.5] Another thing I love about Pratchett's novels is the use of different typography/punctuation conventions to convey non-human speech. The computer gets +++Something Like This+++, Death speaks in small caps (which of course I can't figure out how to do on this machine), and the Auditors get no quotation marks.
[1] Ancient magic makes me think of Card's Enchantment, to which, if I were more awake, I'd draw some more comparisons.
Thursday, October 24, 2013
Terry Pratchett and his sublime word-wielding
Whenever I'm feeling snippy about the state of books, general entertainment, or humanity as a whole[1], I read some Terry Pratchett, and leave with a much more optimistic view on life, the universe, and everything[2].
Pratchett writes social-commentary-slash-fantasy novels. Really, they're a genre unto themselves. It should be included in the library genre sticker system: romance, mystery, sci-fi, Pratchett. The symbol can be an ankh. Or maybe a scythe.
Pratchett's world is vast: his ridiculously-sprawling fantasy series Discworld (obligatory explanation: the Discworld is much like our own, except it is a) rife with magical creatures and b) flat, positioned on the backs of four elephants who in turn are situated atop a giant turtle who swims gently through the universe, its destination known only unto it) has 44 installments and its very own wiki. Thankfully, though, they need not be read in order, as most exist as (at least semi-) stand-alone stories. Kind of like Star Trek: it's nice to go at them in order, as there are certainly themes and some amount of character development, but it's not entirely necessary. You can just pick up wherever and have a good time.
Pratchett writes social-commentary-slash-fantasy novels. Really, they're a genre unto themselves. It should be included in the library genre sticker system: romance, mystery, sci-fi, Pratchett. The symbol can be an ankh. Or maybe a scythe.
Pratchett's world is vast: his ridiculously-sprawling fantasy series Discworld (obligatory explanation: the Discworld is much like our own, except it is a) rife with magical creatures and b) flat, positioned on the backs of four elephants who in turn are situated atop a giant turtle who swims gently through the universe, its destination known only unto it) has 44 installments and its very own wiki. Thankfully, though, they need not be read in order, as most exist as (at least semi-) stand-alone stories. Kind of like Star Trek: it's nice to go at them in order, as there are certainly themes and some amount of character development, but it's not entirely necessary. You can just pick up wherever and have a good time.
Also thankfully, despite having wizards and dragons and dwarves, they are not books-with-maps, which is to say, they're not high fantasy, full of Kings and Kingdoms with made-up names, heroes destined-from-birth-to-save-the-world, and complicated historical/geopolitical scheming [3].
This series is so far reaching, and covers so many topics, that one is bound to run into (or trip over) it at some point. There are many entrances to the world of the Disc, and I can't remember now which of the following two ways I wandered in; pick the one that suits your fancy.
1. Via: The children's/YA portion of Discworld, encompassed in the 4 (so far) Wee Free Men books. They are, like all Pratchett, hilarious, fourth-wall-breaking, punny, probing, insightful, slightly irreverent, practical, and unique. Basic synopsis: Tiffany Aching is a shepherdess-turned-witch in the climbs of damp, Scotland-like mountains whose brother gets kidnapped by the queen of the fairies. Tiffany, being a take-no-nonsense-from-anybody sort of girl and having Second and Third Thoughts to help her through the tricky spots, sets out to rescue him, "armed with only a frying pan and her common sense". Oh, and helped/harried by the Wee Free Men, tiny blue men who are convinced that they are dead and gone to some kind of heaven, as only in heaven would you be allowed such amazing opportunities to drink, fight, and sheep-thieve. This Amazon review reminds us of some of the choicer Feegle names, including "Slightly Bigger Than Wee Jock But Not So Big as Middle-Sized Jock Jock" and "Rob Anybody."
I'll keep you posted.
This series is so far reaching, and covers so many topics, that one is bound to run into (or trip over) it at some point. There are many entrances to the world of the Disc, and I can't remember now which of the following two ways I wandered in; pick the one that suits your fancy.
1. Via: The children's/YA portion of Discworld, encompassed in the 4 (so far) Wee Free Men books. They are, like all Pratchett, hilarious, fourth-wall-breaking, punny, probing, insightful, slightly irreverent, practical, and unique. Basic synopsis: Tiffany Aching is a shepherdess-turned-witch in the climbs of damp, Scotland-like mountains whose brother gets kidnapped by the queen of the fairies. Tiffany, being a take-no-nonsense-from-anybody sort of girl and having Second and Third Thoughts to help her through the tricky spots, sets out to rescue him, "armed with only a frying pan and her common sense". Oh, and helped/harried by the Wee Free Men, tiny blue men who are convinced that they are dead and gone to some kind of heaven, as only in heaven would you be allowed such amazing opportunities to drink, fight, and sheep-thieve. This Amazon review reminds us of some of the choicer Feegle names, including "Slightly Bigger Than Wee Jock But Not So Big as Middle-Sized Jock Jock" and "Rob Anybody."
or
2. Via: boredom. One lazy summer afternoon, or possibly a snow day - it's really not terribly important which, just some long day with nothing to do - I was lacking in library books, and disinclined to read anything on my own shelves, so I raided my mother's books and thought The Color of Magic looked interesting enough...
And now, in my malaise of can't-find-anything-to-read-that-doesn't-annoy, some of my kind-hearted friends have reminded me of the goodness and hilarity that is Pratchett. In recent weeks, I've read Going Postal, Guards! Guards!, and Monstrous Regiment, and am currently working on Small Gods. They deal with, in order, the relevancy of the postal service in the internet/clacks age and con-men; tyrants, kings, and dragons; nationalism, war, gender roles, and the importance of socks; religious fervor/fanaticism, prophets, gods, and tortoises.
Not just anybody could make such disparate things all hang together, but Pratchett does with aplomb. Well, aplomb and jokes. And spot-on observations. Like these gems from Guards! Guards!: "Going Up in the World is a metaphor, which...is like Lying, but more decorative." And this, discussing Ankh-Morpork's (big, charming city of legalized vice [there are Assassins' and Thieves' guilds] ruled by a most practical tyrant) method of dealing with war: "And eventually, under siege, you did what Ankh-Morpork had always done - unbar the gates, let the conquerors in, and make them your own."
Not just anybody could make such disparate things all hang together, but Pratchett does with aplomb. Well, aplomb and jokes. And spot-on observations. Like these gems from Guards! Guards!: "Going Up in the World is a metaphor, which...is like Lying, but more decorative." And this, discussing Ankh-Morpork's (big, charming city of legalized vice [there are Assassins' and Thieves' guilds] ruled by a most practical tyrant) method of dealing with war: "And eventually, under siege, you did what Ankh-Morpork had always done - unbar the gates, let the conquerors in, and make them your own."
I'll keep you posted.
But really. Go read some Pratchett. You'll laugh, (you probably won't cry), you'll look over your shoulder for a Grim Reaper talking in small caps, and feel invigorated by the wit and wisdom of a master author.
xo,
xo,
Devo
[1] Yes, that escalated quickly.
[2] Whoops, wrong writer of weird, British novels.
[1] Yes, that escalated quickly.
[2] Whoops, wrong writer of weird, British novels.
[3] Needless to say, I don't read Game of Thrones. Everything that needs to be known about that can be learned from tumblr.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

HERE IS WHERE YOU PLACE THE HIDDEN FOOTNOTE TEXT.